Loading…
This event has ended. View the official site or create your own event → Check it out
This event has ended. Create your own
View analytic
Sunday, September 27 • 9:00am - 9:32am
Against Jawboning

Sign up or log in to save this to your schedule and see who's attending!

Paper Link

Despite the trend towards strong protection of speech in U.S. Internet regulation, federal and state governments still seek to regulate on-line content. They do so increasingly through informal enforcement measures, such as threats, at the edge of or outside their authority – a practice this Article calls “jawboning.” The Article argues that jawboning is both pervasive and normatively problematic. It uses a set of case studies to illustrate the practice’s prevalence. Next, it explores why Internet intermediaries are structurally vulnerable to jawboning. It then offers a taxonomy of government pressures based on varying levels of compulsion and specifications of authority. To assess jawboning’s legitimacy, the Article employs two methodologies, one grounded in constitutional structure and norms, and the second driven by process-based governance theory. It finds the practice troubling on both accounts. To remediate, the Article considers four interventions: implementing limits through law, imposing reputational consequences, encouraging transparency, and labeling jawboning as normatively illegitimate. In closing, it extends the jawboning analysis to other fundamental constraints on government action, including the Second Amendment. The Article concludes that the legitimacy of informal regulatory efforts should vary based on the extent to which deeper structural limits constrain government’s regulatory power.

 


Moderators
avatar for Harold Feld

Harold Feld

Senior Vice President, Public Knowledge
Harold is Public Knowledge's Senior Vice President. Before becoming Senior Vice President at Public Knowledge, Harold worked as Senior Vice President of Media Access Project, advocating for the public interest in media, telecommunications and technology policy for almost 10 years. Prior to joining MAP, Harold was an associate at Covington & Burling, worked on Freedom of Information Act, Privacy Act, and accountability issues at the... Read More →

Presenters
DB

Derek Bambauer

University of Arizona


Sunday September 27, 2015 9:00am - 9:32am
GMUSL - Room 221

Attendees (6)